Skip to content
Digital Frontier Insights

Why Caicedo Received a Red Card Whereas Bentancur Avoided One: A Tale of Seeming Lack of Uniformity.

Ten-man Chelsea hold Arsenal to a tie in fiery London derby.

Chelsea manager Enzo Maresca was feeling aggrieved. Not because of the dismissal of his midfielder against Arsenal, but over what he perceived to be a notable absence of consistency from the match referees.

It's easy to understand his point. Last month, Spurs player Rodrigo Bentancur was booked for a challenge on Chelsea's captain, a decision the video assistant referee (VAR) upheld. However, when Caicedo was given a yellow for a comparable tackle on the Arsenal player, the VAR intervened to upgrade it to a red card.

"It's a red card, however, why was Bentancur's against Reece James not a dismissal? We, as coaches, we find it difficult to comprehend why they judge in a dissimilar manner," the manager questioned.

So, What Was the Distinction?

Well, outcomes are partly dependent upon the specific official on VAR duty—which makes absolute uniformity very difficult.

Each incident is ever the same, and there were subtle differences between the pair of tackles. Bentancur was largely stepping in, while the Chelsea man left the ground slightly and his point of contact was slightly higher.

There was also a pronounced buckle of the midfielder's joint, a sign a video referee watches for to indicate excessive force, and his boot was shifted on the pitch surface.

Regarding the earlier incident, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel backed the caution for Bentancur by a margin of 4-1, and agreed without dissent no review overturn "on the basis that the challenge was low, marginally tardy and reckless".

This same panel will support the decision to dismiss the Chelsea midfielder, but it may not be long before a similar challenge of its type is judged only a booking.

Was the Video Official Tell the Referee to Show a Caution?

The Chelsea midfielder faces a suspension for three games following his red card against the North London side.

The situation appeared a little confusing initially. Was referee Anthony Taylor being told to caution Caicedo so the foul could be checked?

There is a far simpler reason.

Taylor allowed play to continue for the attacking team as the possession was with Eberechi Eze. When it went out for a throw-in, the official returned to book the offender, who was down injured. Referees are told to delay until an player at fault is standing before showing a card.

So, the delay was not because the VAR was checking; it was since Caicedo was being treated.

Video assistant referee John Brooks may have reached the conclusion that there was sufficient severity for a dismissal, but he has to wait for Taylor to indicate his on-field ruling. The moment Taylor brandished a yellow, the VAR immediately sent him to the monitor because the check had been completed during the medical stoppage.

England Rejects Red Card VAR Recommendation

In another Sunday match, for just the second instance in the top flight, a match official overturned a red card review at the pitchside monitor.

Darren England hadn't given a free-kick against Jhon Arias, so in contrast to the Arsenal incident, the restart was a set piece to the opposing team. The VAR, Bell, believed that the manner the player jumped in with studs showing compromised Boubacar Kamara's well-being.

However, the challenger was off the floor and took a risk, connecting with the upper part of Kamara's boot. It lacked the kind of force usually needed for a red card, although it was not a great tackle.

Should Chelsea's Opening Goal to Be Disallowed for an Offside Offence?

Video review decided that Enzo Fernandez had no impact on the defenders when Trevoh Chalobah scored the first goal for the home side.

Another weekend, and another series of subjective offside decisions.

A possible infringement on the Blues' opener appears to have escaped significant scrutiny.

The Chelsea captain delivered a set-piece in from the left flank, and Chalobah guided a header into the net.

However, there existed a problem. Fernandez was stood in an offside position and was in close proximity to defenders Piero Hincapie and Mosquera.

Did Fernandez influence the actions of either defender? Had the Chelsea player not been there, would there have been a greater opportunity of stopping the goal?

Fernandez did not try to play the ball, and although he was not physically contesting with Mosquera, he had his hand on the other's shoulder.

One could argue a compelling argument for offside, so it returns us to a issue of consistency once again.

Did Hincapie Deserve Red for an Elbow?

Piero Hincapie was in the lineup for the Gunners with their first-choice defenders ruled out through fitness issues.

The incident occurred shortly after the first red card. Hincapie jumped for a high ball with the Chelsea player, and the Chelsea defender sustained contact through an impact by the elbow on his head.

"I asked the official, he told me that it was not an elbow," the Chelsea manager said. "That was what they said. Chalobah suffered a black eye, with ice at half-time. But they decide in a different way."

Match officials are advised not to make decisions based solely on a potential injury, though it occurs sometimes. A footballer can receive a gash or a bruise from many kinds of contact, so it would not be a sound basis.

Similar to serious foul play, officials have a set of criteria they assess for a potential elbow offence.

  • Did it involve an abnormal movement of going for a high ball?
  • Did the player a clenched fist, which indicates malicious intent?
  • Was the elbow swung or lifted to create force?

None of these applied, so a caution was deemed sufficient.

About the author

Erin Rowe

A software engineer and tech writer passionate about AI ethics and open-source projects, with over a decade of industry experience.

Digital Frontier Insights

Type to search articles.